coq/coq


1999

August

The project started with an initial revision by filliatr , laying down the foundation with a new repository initialized from cvs2svn. This was straightforward—just the basics.

The focus quickly shifted to organizing the code. filliatr separated ancien names into names and sign, making the structure clearer. A list of changes was created to track progress. Functionality expanded with the addition of dyn, various utility functions, and modules like Closure and Reduction.

The project evolved further with documentation and code generation improvements. filliatr removed the -nowarning option, which was deemed unhealthy, and began making the type system more robust by ensuring universes were always adjusted. By the end of the month, the core could compile and link, and inductive types were added, albeit without singleton types yet.

The commits reflect a focused effort on clarity, functionality, and an evolving type system. Each change built on the last, demonstrating a clear trajectory toward a more structured and functional codebase.

filliatr
F
(no author)
(
September

The project took significant steps forward this month. filliatr cleaned up the codebase by removing unnecessary constructors and created a new structure for modules, including Libobject and Summary. This simplification laid the groundwork for future development.

Next, a lexer was initiated, followed by establishing a testing framework with test-suite/ and toplevel/. The groundwork for minicoq was laid with rudimentary grammar and commands, addressing core functionality like inductive definitions and type checking. As the month progressed, filliatr tackled various bugs, refining the handling of types and ensuring that arities were stored correctly.

Documentation received attention as well, with efforts directed towards improving clarity. The focus on practical functionality over theoretical perfection is clear. Each change led to a more coherent structure, preparing the project for the next stages of development.

filliatr
F
October

The project made tangible progress this month. filliatr focused on documentation, setting up a clearer interface for users and developers alike. This is essential; clean documentation often gets overlooked but is critical for long-term maintainability.

Notable structural changes followed. Variables were repositioned, first moving existential variables out of the kernel, then back in a more organized manner. This constant shuffling may seem trivial, but it reflects a deeper effort to achieve clarity in how components interact.

Modules like Logic, Proof_trees, and Refiner were added, expanding functionality while maintaining a coherent design. The introduction of unsafe_env to manage existential variables' environments signals a shift towards more robust handling of types. The addition of tactics and discrimination nets further enriches the project's capabilities.

Herbelin chipped in with type handling improvements, solidifying the groundwork laid by filliatr . Each change builds on the last, steering the project toward a cleaner and more functional codebase.

filliatr
F
herbelin
H
November

Herbelin initiated improvements by enhancing error reporting for ill-formed recursion bodies. Precision in error messages matters; vague messages lead to frustration and wasted time.

Filliatr focused on cleaning up the codebase, addressing unnecessary constructors, and eliminating double semicolons. These might seem like small adjustments, but they contribute to a cleaner, more maintainable code. The introduction of generic equality for Sets and Maps makes the framework more versatile.

New modules like Bij, Gmap, and Tactics were added, expanding functionality without compromising clarity. Each addition is deliberate, steering the project toward a more robust structure. Herbelin and Filliatr collaborated on foundational work, laying the groundwork for future features and integrations.

Finally, Filliatr worked on porting components like Evarutil and Astterm, confirming that the project is moving forward to a more complete state. The integration of these modules signals readiness for further development.

filliatr
F
herbelin
H
December

Filliatr kicked off significant changes by renaming components for clarity. Typing became Safe_typing, and unsafe_env transformed into env. These tweaks may seem minor, but they signal a commitment to maintaining a clean and understandable codebase.

The addition of new modules such as Pfedit, Egrammar, and Metasyntax expanded functionality. Filliatr also focused on debugging and improving existing features, evident from the fixes to construct_reference and the introduction of pretty-printers for easier debugging. It’s clear that the focus is on refining the existing structure rather than adding unnecessary complexity.

Herbelin contributed by improving error messaging and refining data types. The introduction of new types like constructor and inductive in Term indicates a move toward clearer type management. Each commit reflects a methodical approach to enhancing the project, aiming for a robust and maintainable codebase.

filliatr
F
herbelin
H
barras
B

2000

January

Herbelin started with a series of renames, changing command to constr for better clarity. This reflects a focus on making the codebase more intuitive. Following this, Herbelin restructured the printer and parser, which is critical for maintaining a clean and efficient workflow.

Multiple restructuring commits aimed at improving error handling and code clarity. The move to eliminate unnecessary coercions and clean up parsing files shows a commitment to reducing clutter. Each change, even minor ones, contributes to a more maintainable project.

Filliatr made a significant push after the holiday break, adding new features like tactics/Equality and addressing bugs in the discharge process. This effort indicates progress, albeit with some rough edges. The ongoing updates and meticulous restructuring suggest a methodical path toward a more robust and coherent system, laying the groundwork for future enhancements.

herbelin
H
filliatr
F
March

Herbelin pushed through a series of practical updates. The addition of matrix_transpose expands functionality where it was previously lacking. This change is straightforward but necessary for handling matrix operations better.

Error handling got a boost with the capture of exceptions when the environment is empty. This ensures debugging doesn’t fail due to a missing context, which is a common pain point in software development.

Naming matters, and Herbelin recognized that by renaming ppterm0 to ppterm. Such clarity in naming reduces confusion and makes the code easier to navigate.

Lastly, the cleanup of check_pos indicates a focus on maintaining a tidy codebase. Each of these commits reflects a commitment to usability and clarity, which are crucial for long-term maintainability.

herbelin
H
September

Herbelin kicked off the latest phase of development with a series of cleanups and corrections. A minor fix for make doc streamlined documentation generation, ensuring that the project's outputs remain accurate and up-to-date. Following that, a general cleanup aimed at tidying up the codebase reflects a consistent effort to maintain clarity.

The focus then shifted towards significant architectural improvements. The introduction of parameterization in reduction functions and the merging of Closure.stack with a new stack abstraction signals a deeper rethinking of the underlying structure. These changes aren't just cosmetic; they lay the groundwork for more efficient processing and a clearer codebase.

The updates continued with further abstractions and the integration of functions into Tacred. As Filliatr contributed to dependency updates, the project shows signs of a concerted effort to enhance robustness while tackling bugs and refining error messages. Each commit builds on the last, indicating a methodical approach to development that prioritizes clarity and functionality.

herbelin
H
coq
C
filliatr
F
October

Herbelin started by eliminating unnecessary code, a clear sign that the project is moving towards a leaner, more efficient codebase. Following this, the removal of deprecated structures and types indicates a focus on simplifying the architecture. The relocation of reference and binder_kind from Term to Rawterm is a structural shift meant to enhance clarity.

The renaming of functions like map_constr_with_named_binders shows a commitment to better naming conventions. Naming is crucial; it reduces confusion and aids navigation. The continuous removal of irrelevant casts and obsolete code demonstrates that clutter is not tolerated here.

Error handling received attention too, with improvements in how exceptions are managed, particularly in relation to empty contexts. This approach not only aids debugging but also contributes to overall robustness. Each commit builds on previous efforts, reflecting a methodical approach to both clarity and functionality.

herbelin
H
filliatr
F
November

The project kicked off with a straightforward goal: improve the structure. Initial commits focused on cleaning up unnecessary code, relocating elements for better organization, and fixing minor bugs. The first few messages reflect this clarity of purpose, with Herbelin setting the tone by moving items to more logical places and addressing small glitches.

As the development progressed, the focus shifted to grammar rules and implicit handling, a clear sign that the foundation was solidifying. Filliatr joined in, removing XML dependencies and separating calculations from declarations. This isn't just about tidiness; it's about ensuring the code can evolve without getting bogged down by past decisions.

Error handling has been a recurring theme. Multiple commits addressed bugs, particularly those affecting local definitions and context management. Each fix peeled back layers of complexity, revealing a cleaner, more robust system. By the end of this period, the project had evolved with clearer pathways for expansion, better error reporting, and a general commitment to simplicity.

herbelin
H
filliatr
F
delahaye
D
mohring
M
mayero
M
December

The project kicked off with Filliatr laying the groundwork. The initial commits focused on essential revisions, adding syntax files and configuring the environment with autoconf. These early steps established a clear direction.

As development progressed, Herbelin took the reins, renaming critical files and refining search patterns. The emphasis was on clarity and usability, as seen in the updates to SearchPattern and SearchRewrite. Each change was practical, aimed at making the code more accessible and maintainable.

Contributions continued with incremental improvements. Delahaye introduced enhancements to the tactic language, reflecting an ongoing commitment to functionality. By the end of the period, the codebase was more organized, with better naming conventions and a clearer structure, setting the stage for future growth.

herbelin
H
filliatr
F
delahaye
D

2001

January

Herbelin kicked off the latest round of commits with a focus on syntax projects. This wasn’t just a cosmetic change; it was about laying the groundwork for better code readability and organization. The project needed clarity, and that’s exactly what was addressed.

The emphasis on refining syntax structures signals a shift towards a more structured approach. This isn't just about making things look nicer—it's about making sure that anyone diving into the code can understand the logic quickly. As the team moves forward, these foundational changes will make future enhancements smoother and less prone to errors.

Ultimately, this is about practicality. A cleaner structure means less time spent deciphering code and more time dedicated to building features. It’s hard to argue against that.

herbelin
H
March

Filliatr started by cleaning up the project with a commit that addressed some core identifiers. This wasn’t just a minor adjustment; it laid the groundwork for improved clarity and structure. Next, they tackled the Correctness feature, even though it wasn't compiling yet. The move signaled a commitment to enhancing the project's capabilities, with the understanding that foundational work must come before functionality.

Further commits from Filliatr introduced beta-reduction and organized test directories. This showed a clear effort to streamline both the extraction process and modularity. It’s about creating a framework where future features can be built more easily.

Mohring contributed by introducing proofs and lemmas related to boolean logic. This was a strategic move. Adding these fundamental elements strengthens the project's logical foundation, making it easier to build upon. The emphasis on structured extraction and logical proofs will ultimately facilitate more robust feature development.

filliatr
F
mohring
M
letouzey
L
April

The project began with a focus on cleanup and bug fixing. Filliatr swiftly resolved an error related to even/odd interpretations, ensuring the foundations were solid. The mention of “à faire” indicates a work-in-progress mindset, typical of software development.

Next, Filliatr shifted to restructuring various components, opting for ml_pop instead of ml_lift and addressing empty inductives. This was about refining the extraction logic and improving clarity in the codebase. The introduction of underscores for proposition variables and parentheses around constructor arguments were practical choices aimed at enhancing readability.

As the groundwork stabilized, Bertot introduced significant enhancements like enabling proof by induction on non-inductive types and ensuring the parser recognized essential constructors. This was about making the system more powerful and user-friendly.

Throughout these iterations, the emphasis remained on clarity and functionality. Each commit reinforced the project’s foundation, making future enhancements more straightforward and less error-prone. This is what sustainable software development looks like.

filliatr
F
bertot
B
mohring
M
herbelin
H
delahaye
D
courant
C
coq
C
barras
B
barras-local
B
letouzey
L
mayero
M
werner
W
June

Clrenard added documentation for the Setoid_replace tactic. This isn't just about writing; it's about making the tool easier to use. Documentation can often be an afterthought, but it’s essential. Without clear guidance, users are left floundering, unsure of how to leverage new features effectively.

By prioritizing documentation, the project acknowledges a fundamental truth: code is only as useful as the understanding behind it. Clear documentation can save countless hours of confusion and frustration. This commit reinforces the notion that a well-documented tool is a more powerful tool.

clrenard
C
September

herbelin kicked things off with some much-needed spell-checking. Small changes like this matter; they keep the documentation professional and clear. Next, he updated the Fact/Remark sections, showing that even the foundational elements of the project weren’t immune to revisions.

Documentation continued to be a priority, with herbelin adding details for NewInduction, NewDestruct, LetTac, and Assert. Clear documentation isn’t just a nicety; it’s essential for users who need to understand complex functionalities. Letouzey followed suit, refining the documentation for Show Intro(s).

As the project evolved, adjustments to syntax were made, particularly concerning Extract Constant and Extract Inlined Constant—tweaks that enhance usability. Herbelin also focused on user warnings to catch deliberate errors, reinforcing the tool’s reliability.

Consistent updates and bug fixes, including a missing } and various V7.1 updates, kept the codebase healthy. This steady stream of commits illustrates a commitment to clarity and usability that defines good software development.

herbelin
H
letouzey
L
clrenard
C
desmettr
D
October

herbelin started by refreshing the project’s introductory documentation and correcting typos. It’s straightforward: if users can't read the documentation, they can't use the software effectively. Small changes matter, and keeping things tidy sets a solid foundation.

The focus quickly shifted to improving features. herbelin added functionalities like Intros Until, Injection, and Discriminate, all while ensuring that the documentation kept pace. Each feature added is only as good as the clarity around it. If users don’t know how to use these tools, they may as well not exist.

There were also necessary fixes, like correcting oversight in subtype cases, which reinforce the system’s robustness. The consistent updates, particularly related to V7.1, reflect an ongoing commitment to quality and usability. This isn’t just maintenance; it’s about making sure that the codebase remains reliable and that users can trust it to work as intended.

herbelin
H
bertot
B
November

filliatr made an important update by addressing the cible coq.info. This isn't just a minor tweak; it indicates that the project is actively refining its informational resources. Clear, accessible information is crucial for users navigating complex software.

Maintaining up-to-date documentation is often overlooked, but it’s essential. If users can’t find reliable information, they’re likely to struggle with the software. Each update, no matter how small, contributes to a more user-friendly experience. This commitment to clarity shows that the project values usability and recognizes that documentation is as vital as code.

In the world of software development, clarity in documentation can make or break a user’s experience. filliatr's focus on improving this aspect keeps the project on solid ground.

filliatr
F
December

barras added a new command, Back, which expands the project's functionality. It’s a straightforward addition, but it reflects a commitment to user needs. Features should evolve based on what users require, and this command appears to address that.

A few days later, barras tackled an issue with the HTML rendering of tabbing in the Ltac documentation. Poor documentation presentation can frustrate users, making this fix essential for maintaining clarity. It’s often the small, behind-the-scenes work that keeps the user experience intact.

herbelin focused on updating to version 7.2, implementing new features like ClearBody, Assert H:=t, and Canonical Structure. Each feature enriches the project, but without clear documentation, they risk being underutilized. Alongside these updates, herbelin also issued a warning regarding a parsing error, showing awareness of potential user pitfalls. This ongoing attention to detail ensures that the project remains robust and user-friendly.

herbelin
H
barras
B

2002

January

herbelin pushed two updates labeled simply as MAJ. These commits might seem vague, but they suggest ongoing refinement. When a project is in constant flux, it’s essential to keep the momentum going, even if the details aren’t always clear.

mohring integrated credit for version 7.2, acknowledging contributions that often get overlooked. In software, recognition matters. It fosters collaboration and keeps morale high. A few days later, another commit from mohring came with no message. A blank log can happen, but it serves as a reminder that not every change needs an elaborate explanation.

herbelin corrected a typo. Typos may seem trivial, but they can erode trust. Attention to detail is crucial in software development.

letouzey updated the documentation for the extraction feature in version 7.2. Good documentation is as important as code; without it, users can feel lost. Additional typo corrections and fixes followed, showing a commitment to clarity. This ongoing focus on detail, both in code and documentation, is what keeps the project usable and relevant.

herbelin
H
letouzey
L
mohring
M
March

herbelin made a commit that provided clarifications on convertibility and the Cbv/Lazy tactics. This isn't just about adding more words; it's about making sure that users understand the nuances of these tactics. In software, clarity can mean the difference between effective use and confusion.

When a project grows, so do its complexities. The focus here is on improving user comprehension, which is fundamental for any software that aims to be useful. Clear explanations help users make better decisions, reducing frustration and errors.

The ongoing refinement is crucial. Each detail matters, and this commitment to enhancing understanding reflects a broader trend in the project's evolution. As the codebase expands, the need for precise documentation becomes even more pressing.

herbelin
H
April

letouzey added examples to the documentation. It’s a straightforward move, but examples matter. They clarify usage and help users absorb complex concepts. Without them, documentation is often just words on a page, leaving users in the dark.

The next commit from letouzey removed an outdated paragraph about extraction. Keeping documentation relevant is crucial. Obsolete information can mislead users, and eliminating it reflects a commitment to accuracy.

herbelin introduced new features like Rename and Pose. These additions expand the toolset available to users, but without clear documentation, they can cause confusion.

courant contributed to the documentation for Intuition and Tauto. Good documentation is essential for understanding how to leverage these features effectively.

Finally, filliatr mentioned coq-inferior.el. A small commit, but recognition of integrations is important for fostering collaboration. Each of these changes, whether large or small, plays a part in refining the project.

letouzey
L
courant
C
filliatr
F
herbelin
H

2007

July

thery added a proof for sub. This isn't just a line of code; it's a foundational piece that enhances the project’s reliability. Proofs matter in software development, especially in systems that rely on formal verification.

jforest tackled a compilation warning. It may seem minor, but cleaning up warnings is an essential part of maintaining code quality. Ignoring warnings can lead to bigger issues down the line.

corbinea improved the bootstrapping and Makefile system. A robust build system is critical. If building the project is a hassle, fewer people will use it.

letouzey removed slow first-order calls in FSetAVL, a necessary optimization after earlier changes. Performance matters. Users notice when the software is sluggish.

herbelin refined the Numbers directory, continuing the work started in the Num directory. This kind of organization is key to keeping the project navigable as it grows.

lmamane made a series of improvements to the Makefile, ensuring it works more reliably with C files. A good build process saves everyone time and frustration.

emakarov updated the axiomatization of numbers, pushing the project forward in its mathematical capabilities. Each of these contributions, whether big or small, is about making the software better and more usable.

lmamane
L
letouzey
L
corbinea
C
emakarov
E
herbelin
H
thery
T
barras
B
notin
N
jforest
J
msozeau
M
roconnor
R
aspiwack
August

The build system is now more robust. lmamane fixed BSD compatibility issues by eliminating the use of the -printf action in find. This isn't just about compatibility; it ensures that the build process remains reliable across different environments. In subsequent commits, lmamane further refined the build system by preventing recursion into version control metadata, streamlining file management.

msozeau added a new tactic for generalizing instantiated inductive predicates, enhancing the toolset for users. This was followed by organizing the Program tactics into a dedicated directory, making them easier to access and understand. Improved documentation accompanies these changes, ensuring users know how to leverage the new features effectively.

Multiple bug fixes and optimizations followed, touching on everything from type handling to the clarity of error messages. herbelin contributed to this by cleaning up unnecessary code and addressing specific bugs, which helps maintain the project's integrity. Each commit, whether it resolves a bug or improves documentation, builds toward a more reliable and user-friendly software experience.

herbelin
H
notin
N
msozeau
M
lmamane
L
emakarov
E
jforest
J
roconnor
R
September

herbelin expanded local trivial definitions in the projection step during the instantiation of an evar. This change enhances the tool's flexibility and efficiency.

msozeau provided clarity on the measure and wf modifiers. Clear documentation helps users understand complex concepts, which is crucial for adoption.

Another refinement by herbelin introduced a more sophisticated algorithm for handling variable aliases in the instance inversion function. It now detects incompatible distinct inversions and employs a new heuristic for compatible ones. This is not just a minor tweak; it makes the system smarter about managing complexity.

barras fixed icons twice, which might seem trivial but contributes to a polished user interface. Good UI matters.

herbelin continued with improvements, iterating on sub-terms in guard condition checks and standardizing naming conventions. Consistency in naming helps developers maintain focus.

bertot addressed several bugs in recdef.ml4, correcting parenthetical issues and cleaning up remnants from earlier modifications. Bug fixes are the lifeblood of a stable codebase. Each commit, regardless of its size, is part of the ongoing effort to enhance reliability.

herbelin
H
barras
B
bertot
B
msozeau
M

2009

March

msozeau kicked off a series of bug fixes in coqdoc, addressing issues reported by users. Clarity is critical in documentation, and these fixes ensure that LaTeX environments parse correctly and comments are read without errors.

lmamane shifted coqdep_boot to run in stage 1 instead of stage 2, streamlining the build process. This change, along with a few tweaks to how binaries and plugins are handled, makes the overall system less prone to error.

letouzey worked on refining the ocamlbuild system, improving its handling of files and dependencies. Despite some challenges, like slow detection of unchanged files, the results are a more robust build process.

msozeau then turned his attention to the Program module, rewriting the Fixpoint to allow greater flexibility in recursive definitions. This was not just a minor update; it added significant power to how users can define functions, accommodating multiple arguments and relations.

Overall, these commits reflect a steady progression towards a more reliable and flexible system, with each contributor focusing on specific pain points. The momentum is tangible.

letouzey
L
msozeau
M
glondu
G
lmamane
L
herbelin
H
April

The recent updates to the project center around improving both functionality and user experience. letouzey made several enhancements to ocamlbuild, including importing Coq_config directly and simplifying dependency management. This not only cleans up the code but also streamlines the build process, making it less error-prone.

msozeau has been focused on fixing bugs and refining features. The updates to handling newlines in comments and the evars_of_named_context bug illustrate a commitment to ensuring the system behaves predictably. His move of setoid_rewrite to a modular structure significantly improves proof production time and flexibility in strategies.

herbelin contributed by addressing various bugs, including those related to unification and error reporting. His continuous focus on cleaning up and standardizing the codebase enhances maintainability, which is crucial for a complex system like this.

The narrative here is clear: each contributor tackles specific issues, leading to a more reliable and efficient system. The evolution is marked not just by new features but by the steady elimination of pain points.

msozeau
M
herbelin
H
letouzey
L
barras
B
vsiles
V
notin
N
soubiran
S
May

msozeau focuses on improving the eauto system. He's added depth and subgoal information to proof searches and introduced a new tactic autoapply foo using hints. These changes give users better control over unfolding, which is critical for complex proofs. The bug fix in the Lambda case and work on Proper and subrelation hints shows a commitment to maintaining completeness while cutting down the search space.

bertot contributes a theorem that enhances reasoning capabilities at the level of integers. This isn’t just a minor addition; it improves the mathematical framework significantly.

herbelin adds new hints for equivalence declarations and centralizes functions related to evaluable global references. His tweaks improve code clarity and functionality, although some manual factorization was necessary due to limitations in camlp4.

The theme in these updates is clear: contributors are focused on enhancing functionality and refining existing systems. Each change, whether it’s a bug fix or a new feature, contributes to a more powerful and reliable environment for users.

msozeau
M
herbelin
H
fbesson
F
barras
B
bertot
B
vgross
V
vsiles
V

2011

February

glondu removed TheoryList because it was obsolete. Its contents had mostly migrated to List, making it unnecessary. This is a straightforward cleanup.

pboutill made the code compatible with versions earlier than 3.12. This kind of backward compatibility is often overlooked but crucial for users on older systems.

msozeau optimized Evd.fold for speed by eliminating unneeded existential variables. He also fixed issues with globality flags for typeclass instance hints, allowing users to remove hints based on lemma names. These changes improve performance and usability.

letouzey focused on refactoring and simplifying various components, such as splitting delta_resolver into two tables, which enhances efficiency. He also clarified the Class_tactics code and improved how argument scopes are handled, making the codebase more maintainable.

Each commit addresses specific issues, leading to a cleaner, more efficient system. The focus is on practical improvements rather than flashy features.

letouzey
L
msozeau
M
glondu
G
pottier
P
pboutill
March

The project has seen a series of focused improvements aimed at refining the codebase and enhancing user experience. letouzey initiated the changes by propagating recent kernel modifications to the checker, addressing issues with code duplication. The cleanup efforts continued with glondu , who added eta-expansion and performed further cleanup, ensuring a more robust and streamlined checker.

msozeau made significant strides in usability and efficiency, allowing the setting of specific transparent states for local hint databases and fixing typeclass constraints with specialize. He also simplified proofs in Permutation and improved error handling in unification, laying a better foundation for future enhancements.

The ongoing work by herbelin has refined the error messaging system and improved module typing error handling, indicating a commitment to clarity. The introduction of a timeout tactical by letouzey aims to control execution time but comes with caveats about machine dependency. Each commit contributes not just to maintaining but also to evolving the system, prioritizing substance over superficial changes.

letouzey
L
herbelin
H
msozeau
M
glondu
G
bgregoir
B
pottier
P

2012

June

ppedrot made a series of straightforward yet impactful changes to the CoqIDE. The addition of a .mli file to pretyping/program.ml sets the stage for clearer module interfacing. A small code compaction and factoring followed, which tidies up the code and makes it easier to navigate.

The introduction of a Deque module into CLib will enhance performance. Fixes to string width printing and automatic adjustment of printing width for goal displays directly address usability issues. The awkward copy and paste mechanism was also fixed, improving the user experience significantly.

Further refinements included adding a show_margin_right option and better separation of answers and messages in CoqIDE. Various display improvements rounded out the changes. Each commit reflects a focus on practical enhancements, marking a steady evolution of the project rather than flashy updates.

ppedrot
P
July

The project evolved through a series of pragmatic adjustments, primarily led by aspiwack and letouzey . aspiwack improved the goal display, making it more intuitive by reordering messages and refining how open goals are printed. This straightforward change made interactions smoother, especially after completing subproofs.

letouzey contributed a new annotation for compatibility, which allows for better handling of legacy notations while keeping the codebase clean. They also favored modern naming conventions, enhancing clarity in the code without sacrificing functionality. The decision to remove redundant tactics and optimize the printing processes further streamlined the development experience.

In parallel, bug fixes from msozeau and herbelin addressed critical issues, ensuring that error messages were meaningful and that edge cases in type handling were resolved. Each commit reflects a focused effort to refine the user experience and maintain a robust codebase, prioritizing practical fixes over unnecessary complexity.

letouzey
L
pboutill
aspiwack
ppedrot
P
herbelin
H
msozeau
M
courtieu
C

2013

October

No activity this month.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot

2014

February

No activity this month.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot
March

The project saw a series of targeted fixes and enhancements this month. Pierre-Marie Pédrot initiated significant improvements by addressing issues with Pervasives.equality and generic equalities across various modules. These fixes are essential for ensuring consistent behavior in equality checks, which is fundamental to the integrity of the system.

Enrico Tassi made strides in the STM (Software Transactional Memory) area, optimizing how universe constraints are handled and improving the delegation policy for proofs. This change means less overhead for smaller proofs, making the system more efficient.

The team also shifted towards using HMaps for various data structures, enhancing performance. This change, along with the removal of outdated compatibility layers in the tactic engine, signifies a move towards a cleaner, more efficient codebase. These adjustments may seem incremental, but they collectively improve the maintainability and speed of the system.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Enrico Tassi
Pierre Boutillier
Virgile Prevosto
Guillaume Melquiond
Pierre Letouzey
Enrico Tassi
E
Jason Gross
Maxime Dénès
April

The project evolved through a series of focused bug fixes and enhancements. Pierre Boutillier tackled multiple bugs, including a better error message for ambiguous object names and a normalization fix for implicit arguments. Such changes improve clarity and reduce confusion for developers.

Hugo Herbelin made strides in handling existential variables, refining how they propagate through the system. This shift simplifies the treatment of evar/evar problems and addresses a looping issue, directly targeting inefficiencies that can slow down the process.

Enrico Tassi enhanced the resilience of Software Transactional Memory (STM) to specific commands, making the system more robust. Meanwhile, Thomas Refis cleaned up the .merlin configuration, reducing unnecessary complexity and potential errors during development.

Each change, while small on its own, contributes to a more stable and maintainable codebase. There's no fluff here; the team is focused on making the software reliable.

Hugo Herbelin
Pierre Boutillier
Guillaume Melquiond
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Thomas Refis
Jason Gross
Julien Forest
Enrico Tassi
September

The simpl syntax just got a bit more flexible. Arnaud Spiwack added a delta flag, allowing commands like simpl -[plus minus] div2. While it’s not utilized immediately, this sets the stage for more nuanced operations down the line.

This change might seem small, but extending syntax is crucial. It opens up future possibilities for optimization and expression. The team isn’t just patching holes; they’re thinking ahead.

Incremental improvements like this are what make a project sustainable. Each addition builds a foundation for the next, creating a codebase that can handle complexity as it grows.

Arnaud Spiwack
November

The project just added a foundational feature: handling results on lists. Sébastien Hinderer rolled out this initial implementation, marking a significant step in the software's capability.

This isn't just about lists; it's about what comes next. With results now manageable, the groundwork is laid for more complex data operations. It’s a shift that goes beyond surface-level adjustments.

Building out features like this is how you evolve software. Each new capability adds layers of functionality, making it easier to tackle future challenges. It’s a clear signal that the team is thinking about what users will need next, rather than just fixing what’s broken.

Sébastien Hinderer
December

The project shifted towards a cleaner exception handling model. Pierre-Marie Pédrot removed the clunky Exninfo hacks in favor of a dedicated type for exceptions. This streamlined approach required modifications across all functions that handle exceptions, enhancing clarity and maintainability. However, the initial implementation wasn't thread-safe, prompting a follow-up patch to introduce proper safety features.

Incremental improvements continued with Hugo Herbelin refining error reporting related to pattern matching and unification. These changes, though nuanced, aimed at providing clearer insights when things go wrong. Matthieu Sozeau and others contributed to fixing various bugs, which is the unsung work that keeps the project stable.

In the background, Enrico Tassi simplified state management and improved the CoqIDE user experience. These adjustments might seem minor, but they address persistent issues that could derail user interactions.

Amidst these fixes and enhancements, Sébastien Hinderer added features related to lists, further expanding the project's capabilities. The continuous focus on refining and optimizing is what makes this project sustainable. Each change, whether minor or major, builds the foundation for future enhancements.

Enrico Tassi
Hugo Herbelin
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Pierre Courtieu
Matthieu Sozeau
Arnaud Spiwack
Pierre Boutillier
Sébastien Hinderer
Xavier Clerc
Pierre Letouzey
Pierre Corbineau
P
Julien Forest
Maxime Dénès
mlasson

2015

June

Arnaud Spiwack added a flag in VernacFixpoint and VernacCoFixpoint to control assuming guardedness. This is a practical change that allows developers to specify whether they want to enforce guardedness in their definitions. It's a small tweak, but it gives users more control over how they manage recursion, which can prevent subtle bugs.

The decision to add this flag reflects a clear need in the user community. Instead of imposing strict rules, it lets developers choose their level of rigor. This isn’t just about fixing specific problems; it’s about making the tool more flexible and accommodating the diverse ways people use it.

This is the kind of incremental improvement that matters. It’s not flashy, but it’s necessary for a tool that aims to serve a broad audience. Each small change like this builds towards a more robust and user-friendly project.

Arnaud Spiwack
July

Arnaud Spiwack introduced a Guarded flag to the assumption tokens, allowing developers to specify whether they want to enforce guardedness in their recursive definitions. This change isn’t just a minor add-on; it gives users critical flexibility in managing recursion, addressing a real need without imposing unnecessary strictness.

The temporary syntax for assuming guardedness in fixed points, Fixpoint Assume[Guarded] …, was a necessary step, albeit with its own quirks—the alternate syntax broke the parser. This reflects a common issue in software development: the simplest solutions often lead to unexpected complications.

Spreading the Guarded flag from syntax to kernel proved to be more complex than anticipated. A boolean wasn’t sufficient here; it hinted at deeper structural needs in the codebase. This isn’t just about adding features; it’s about recognizing the intricate web of dependencies and improving the overall robustness of the project.

Arnaud Spiwack
Hugo Herbelin
August

Rich printing of goals was added. This isn’t just about making things look nicer; it’s about improving clarity in the development process. When you can see your goals presented in a richer format, it’s easier to understand what’s happening in your code.

Next, standard printing tags were integrated into CoqIDE. This was a necessary step to ensure consistency across the interface. Without these tags, the output can become confusing, leading to misunderstandings that waste time.

To further enhance usability, tag preferences were plugged into buffer printing. This gives developers the ability to customize how information is displayed. Customization is crucial; not everyone works the same way, and a one-size-fits-all approach rarely fits anyone well.

Finally, rich printing of messages was implemented. This rounds out the focus on clarity and usability. The cumulative effect of these changes is a more informative and user-friendly environment, which is what developers need to work effectively.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot
September

The project took a significant step forward with the enforcement of Set <= i for all Type occurrences. This change tightened the rules around universes, preventing potential inconsistencies that could arise in complex code.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot focused on improving the user experience in CoqIDE. By removing unnecessary canonicalization of messages, developers get clearer output. The introduction of rich printing for protocol failures and primitives enhances feedback during development, making it easier to understand what's going wrong when issues arise.

Matthieu Sozeau made a series of important adjustments to manage universes more effectively. He ensured that all universes are at least Set, addressed several bugs related to evar initialization, and refined how universes interact with side effects in proofs. These changes are not just about fixing bugs; they reflect an ongoing effort to produce a more reliable and usable system.

As the work progressed, contributors continued to streamline the API and make the internal structures more robust, ensuring that the system remains maintainable.

Matthieu Sozeau
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Guillaume Melquiond
Hugo Herbelin
Arnaud Spiwack
Jason Gross
Enrico Tassi
October

Matthieu Sozeau took charge of universe management, implementing a series of fixes that addressed longstanding bugs. The update checker was refined, and he corrected the handling of template polymorphic constants, which resolved multiple issues. This isn’t just maintenance; it’s critical for keeping the codebase clean and functional.

He also clarified how modules handle polymorphic definitions, ensuring the system enforces rules about universes more strictly. The standard library was updated to require five universes, reinforcing the hierarchy of types. This sets the stage for a more coherent structure moving forward.

Pierre Courtieu made adjustments to the Emacs output mode, adding a new <infomsg> tag to improve how debug messages are displayed. He also fixed a bug in Proof General that prevented certain messages from displaying correctly. These changes are about usability, making it easier for developers to get timely feedback during their work.

Matthieu Sozeau
Pierre Courtieu

2016

February

Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias addressed a critical issue in pp.ml concerning the handling of the Format module. The documentation clearly states that pretty-printing commands require an enclosing box for proper formatting. Yet, the existing code didn’t enforce this rule, leading to potential display problems, particularly when log_via_feedback is activated.

By ensuring that Format is always called with a top-level box, he improved the reliability of message formatting. This isn’t just a minor tweak; it directly affects how developers see output, preventing frustrating mismatches in width and layout.

A small cleanup can lead to significant usability improvements. This change reinforces the importance of adhering to documentation and best practices, ensuring a better experience for everyone involved.

Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
April

The project is undergoing significant refinement, primarily focused on improving the printing and parsing of notations and tactics. Hugo Herbelin introduced a heuristic for adding parentheses in specific cases, which addresses a longstanding issue related to operator precedence. While this fix is a step forward, it still requires further tuning to avoid unnecessary parentheses in certain contexts.

In a series of commits, he streamlined the handling of debug messages, optimized the beautification process, and ensured that parsing respects levels in tactic entries. However, some changes have been reverted as they introduced inconsistencies, highlighting the iterative nature of software development.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot contributed by enhancing the API for tactic notations and cleaning up dead code. These adjustments align the notation resolution process more closely with user-defined maps rather than hardcoded schemes. The project is becoming cleaner and more efficient, but it remains a work in progress as contributors continue to address bugs and refine functionality.

Hugo Herbelin
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Maxime Dénès
Frédéric Besson
Gregory Malecha
Tej Chajed
July

A collision in the handling of meta-variables emerged in recursive notations. Hugo Herbelin tackled this by refining the way the .. meta-variable operates when recursive notations define themselves. This kind of issue can lead to confusion and errors, especially in complex structures. The fix clarifies the intended use of .., making the code more predictable.

Every small fix matters, especially when they prevent deeper issues down the line. This change is a reminder that even seemingly trivial elements of syntax can disrupt logic. Clean, clear code avoids complications later; it's a straightforward principle that sometimes gets lost in the shuffle.

The project continues to evolve, one commit at a time, with each adjustment pushing it closer to reliability and clarity.

Hugo Herbelin
September

A new debugging printer for Genarg.ArgT.t was added. This change improves the ability to trace and understand the state of the program during execution, which is crucial for diagnosing issues. Debugging is often the difference between a smooth development cycle and endless frustration.

Hugo Herbelin is focused on making the codebase easier to work with. Each addition, like this printer, builds on the foundation of clarity and usability. The project isn’t just about fixing bugs; it’s about making the process of finding and fixing them more efficient.

This commitment to refinement shows an understanding that software development is iterative. Small tools can save hours of troubleshooting later on. It's a simple truth: better debugging tools lead to better software.

Hugo Herbelin
October

The evolution of the software project reflects a series of practical, necessary adjustments. Hugo Herbelin fixed a beautifier bug flagged by Emilio , keeping the code clean and functional. This kind of routine maintenance is essential; without it, the user experience suffers.

Maxime Dénès cleaned up type class flags and streamlined compatibility files. Such tidying may seem trivial, but it simplifies future development, reducing cognitive load and potential errors.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot addressed several bugs, including one where the handling of registered objects was flawed, leading to unpredictable behavior. Fixing these issues is about more than just squashing bugs; it’s about ensuring that the system operates as expected under various conditions.

Each commit represents a step toward clarity and functionality. The work is iterative, emphasizing that sometimes the smallest tweaks can prevent headaches down the line.

Hugo Herbelin
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Matthieu Sozeau
Maxime Dénès
Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
Théo Zimmermann
Arnaud Spiwack

2017

March

Hugo Herbelin made a straightforward fix: removed trailing / and \ from directory names on Win32. This isn’t just a cosmetic change; it solves a real problem. Command line tools on Windows choke on trailing slashes.

This commit refines a previous change (e234f3ef) and also addresses an open issue (#5391). It’s a clear example of how small adjustments can eliminate friction for users.

In software development, ignoring these details can lead to unnecessary headaches. Fixing them upfront saves time and effort later. It’s about getting the fundamentals right.

Hugo Herbelin
June

Maxime Dénès added functionality to automate the generation of OSX packages using Travis. Previously, building packages for OSX was a manual hassle. This change means that every time a main branch is updated, a new package is automatically created and made available via Bintray.

Automation like this isn’t just about saving time; it reduces the chance of human error. Manual processes are prone to mistakes, and those mistakes can cascade into bigger problems. By shifting to automated package generation, the team can focus on writing code rather than worrying about the deployment process.

This commit marks a practical step towards better workflow efficiency. It’s a reminder that sometimes the best improvements come from simplifying the mundane.

Maxime Dénès
July

Maxime Dénès made a simple but necessary change to the versioning scheme. By changing 8.7~alpha to 8.7+alpha, he aligned the tags with Git's requirements. This is important because proper tagging will be used to generate version numbers automatically. It’s a straightforward move that lays the groundwork for smoother releases.

Hugo Herbelin addressed a regression in the handling of new goals under version 8.4. The mk_refgoals function was applying full βι-normalization incorrectly. His fix involves simulating part of that normalization process in pose_all_metas_as_evars. While it’s unclear how this compares to prior versions, it’s clear that a better heuristic is preferable to no normalization at all.

He followed up with another fix for the same regression, ensuring that hypotheses created by let and if statements are also βι-normalized. This is about consistency and ensuring that all parts of the logic behave as expected. Each of these changes improves the project incrementally, addressing specific issues without overcomplicating the solution.

Hugo Herbelin
Maxime Dénès
August

A series of straightforward changes drove the evolution of the project this month. Tej Chajed initiated some improvements based on Jason's feedback, which kicked off a wave of refinements. Then, Maxime Dénès merged multiple pull requests, one of which resolved issues with coq_makefile, aligning it better with users' needs.

Hugo Herbelin moved primitive.ml to cPrimitive.ml to avoid conflicts with OCaml. This shift was an essential, if minor, adjustment to maintain compatibility. In parallel, Pierre Letouzey improved the Makefile by ignoring user contributions in file searches, which clarified binary file searches.

Jason Gross focused on enhancing CI error messages to mitigate confusion during failures. His work on the CI system improved clarity, ensuring developers could quickly identify real issues instead of getting lost in irrelevant messages.

Overall, the commits reflect a consistent effort to streamline processes and enhance usability, all while addressing specific, tactical problems.

Maxime Dénès
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Théo Zimmermann
Paul Steckler
Jason Gross
Tej Chajed
Guillaume Melquiond
Matthieu Sozeau
Hugo Herbelin
Amin Timany
Pierre Courtieu
Pierre Letouzey
Gaëtan Gilbert
G
October

Gaëtan Gilbert removed Sorts.contents, a straightforward cleanup that eliminates unnecessary complexity. This kind of simplification is often overlooked but is crucial for keeping the codebase maintainable.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot introduced a homebrew parser to replace the GEXTEND extension points of Camlp5. The new parser isn't particularly clever—it just requires OCaml code to be wrapped in { braces } for proper quoting. Sure, it’s a minor shift in syntax that could frustrate some users, but it’s a necessary step toward a more integrated solution. The type system will handle files using this syntax specifically, requiring a new .mlg extension instead of the old .ml4.

Following that, Pierre-Marie Pédrot ported several components—g_prim, g_constr, g_proofs, and g_vernac—to the new parser. This is methodical work that reflects a commitment to consistency across the project, ensuring everything aligns with the new system.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Gaëtan Gilbert

2018

March

Hugo Herbelin made an important change by swapping Context and Constr, allowing declarations to be defined within Constr. This isn’t just a rearrangement; it enables the use of declaration contexts in the "Case" constructor.

Now Constr encompasses Context, which leads to a more integrated structure. While this change introduces some boilerplate, it’s a necessary step for better organization and clarity in type definitions. The goal is to reduce complexity in how types relate to one another.

This kind of refactoring is often tedious but essential. It lays the groundwork for future enhancements and keeps the codebase aligned with evolving needs.

Hugo Herbelin
April

The project just got an overlay, courtesy of Hugo Herbelin . This isn’t just an addition; it’s a shift in how elements interact. Overlays can streamline processes, allowing layers to work together more effectively.

Adding overlays might sound simple, but it impacts how components are structured and interact. It’s about making the code more modular and easier to manage. This kind of change is critical for future development. It lays the groundwork for more complex features down the line.

Every small enhancement like this is a step toward a more functional and maintainable codebase. It’s not flashy, but it’s necessary.

Hugo Herbelin
May

The latest changes are about simplification. Maxime Dénès tackled the reification of predicates in both the bytecode and native compilers. This wasn’t just a cleanup; it addressed legacy complexities that had piled up over time. Simplifying the representation of return predicates means the code is now more straightforward and easier to work with.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot followed up by sharing the role type between the implementations of side effects. By exploiting a type isomorphism, he eliminated unnecessary algebraic types in the kernel. This is a practical decision; it reduces clutter without losing functionality.

He continued the trend by cleaning up the side-effect API, removing internal functions and types. These changes might seem small, but they make the codebase more focused and maintainable. Each step is about reducing complexity, which is crucial for long-term health.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Maxime Dénès
June

Jasper Hugunin kicked off a series of improvements by implementing uniform parameters in ComInductive, which tightened up how uniform inductives operate. The goal was to eliminate extraneous notations, leading to clearer code.

He continued with a couple of straightforward commits: a new flag for Uniform Inductive Parameters and a test to ensure it worked as intended. Documentation followed shortly, making it easier for others to understand this new feature.

Hugo Herbelin tackled a few bugs related to printing and recursive notation formats, resolving issues that had been causing confusion. Maxime Dénès found and fixed a critical vm_compute segfault, a serious problem that could have led to erroneous behavior in the system.

The project saw further refinement as Gaëtan Gilbert made Environ.globals abstract and streamlined the handling of contexts. Pierre-Marie Pédrot documented changes and added overlays, which enhance the code's modularity and maintainability.

Each of these commits, while seemingly small, contributes to a cleaner, more robust codebase. Complexity continues to be reduced, setting the stage for future development.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Maxime Dénès
Théo Zimmermann
Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
Hugo Herbelin
Gaëtan Gilbert
Jasper Hugunin
Ambroise
Enrico Tassi
Jim Fehrle
Lysxia
Matthieu Sozeau
Michael Soegtrop
Vincent Laporte
Armaël Guéneau
A
Andres Erbsen
A
Cyprien Mangin
July

Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias addressed several critical issues. First, he implemented a workaround that fixed a problem where the printing mechanism didn't split lines correctly at break hints. This was affecting readability and usability.

Next, he resolved a bug in reporting bad recursive notation formats. This was causing confusion, and fixing it removed an unnecessary obstacle for developers.

He then split the primitive numeral parser and printer into three distinct files. This separation improves organization and makes it easier to manage each numeral type individually.

Lastly, he added documentation clarifying that GITURL variables should not end with a trailing .git. This small detail can prevent misconfigurations, streamlining the setup process for users.

Each of these changes contributes to a more reliable and manageable codebase. The focus is on clarity and organization, which is essential for long-term development.

Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
August

Vincent Semeria made a significant contribution with a proof that R is uncountable. This mathematical foundation is crucial and underpins many concepts in the project.

He then tidied up the documentation by fixing the header and the index. Clear documentation is often overlooked but critical for usability.

Finally, he corrected the credits. Recognizing contributions properly is essential for maintaining morale and transparency within the team.

These changes, while not a barrage, address foundational aspects of the project. They improve clarity, organization, and acknowledgment, setting a baseline for future work.

Vincent Semeria
September

Gaëtan Gilbert made significant changes to the attributes system. Moving attributes out of vernacinterp to a new module clarifies the code structure. This separation is crucial for maintainability and understanding.

He eliminated the location field from attributes because it was never set and had no purpose. This cleanup reduces confusion and keeps the codebase lean.

Next, he refined the mk_atts function by removing unnecessary optional arguments. Streamlined functions are easier to use and less prone to errors.

The introduction of command-driven attributes means commands now explicitly request the attributes they require, enforcing better API practices and reducing the risk of unsupported attributes causing issues.

Cyril Cohen contributed by adding a test-suite entry for issue #8544, ensuring that the problem can be reproduced and verified.

Finally, Enrico Tassi fixed an issue with IPatDispatch using tclDISPATCH, addressing the same bug.

These changes improve organization, clarity, and reliability within the codebase.

Gaëtan Gilbert
Cyril Cohen
Enrico Tassi
October

The project evolved significantly as Gaëtan Gilbert focused on generalizing attributes. He made defining #[universes(...)] easier by streamlining the attributes system. This included removing unnecessary complexity, like the is_universe_polymorphism checks, which were irrelevant for funind. Such simplifications lead to a cleaner codebase and a more straightforward understanding of how attributes function.

He introduced command-driven attributes, allowing commands to specify what they need clearly. This change enhances the API's reliability and reduces potential errors. Accompanying these improvements, Hugo Herbelin fixed scope issues with tactic-in-term, ensuring that the right contexts are respected during interpretation.

Contributions from Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias and Théo Zimmermann further refined documentation and setup scripts, all while addressing outstanding issues. The push towards clearer structure and effective documentation shapes a more manageable and user-friendly codebase.

Gaëtan Gilbert
Hugo Herbelin
Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
Maxime Dénès
M
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Yves Bertot
Matthieu Sozeau
Guillaume Melquiond
Théo Zimmermann
Vincent Semeria
Enrico Tassi
November

The documentation got cleaner after Théo Zimmermann fixed typos in the CIC document. A small but necessary step for clarity. Meanwhile, Vincent Semeria ensured that everything was in order by sorting items alphabetically.

Hugo Herbelin tackled a grounding issue related to terms without evars, addressing bug #8224. This is the kind of fix that ensures the system behaves predictably. Gaëtan Gilbert also cleaned up the gitignore for files that appeared with the new mlg setup, eliminating clutter.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot made several merges, including updates to the proof engine documentation and fixes related to tactics and interpretations. The removal of the obsolete Token module further streamlined the codebase, reducing potential confusion.

The introduction of command-driven attributes marks a significant shift in how attributes are handled, promoting better API usage. The project is now more organized and user-friendly, which is what matters most.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Hugo Herbelin
Gaëtan Gilbert
Vincent Laporte
Maxime Dénès
M
Théo Zimmermann
Yves Bertot
Vincent Semeria
Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
December

Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias removed the dependency of abstract on the global proof state. By placing the polymorphic status and name in the read-only part of the monad, he reduced unnecessary coupling within the tactics. The added comments clarify the intent, making the code easier to navigate. Most of the tactics now operate independently of proofs and interp, which is a solid improvement.

Gaëtan Gilbert followed up by adapting the code to changes in coq/coq#8817 regarding SProp. This ensures that the project remains compatible with the latest updates, which is essential for maintaining a healthy codebase. The ongoing effort to simplify dependencies and adapt to external changes reflects a focus on stability and clarity. There’s a clear trend here: eliminating unnecessary complexity leads to a more maintainable system.

Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
Gaëtan Gilbert

2019

January

The recent commits tackle some fundamental issues in the codebase. Gaëtan Gilbert fixed bug #9432, which involved the canonical structure and coercion accepting universe binders when defining new constants. This change should make the behavior of constants more predictable and intuitive.

In a subsequent commit, Gaëtan Gilbert separated variance and universe fields in inductive types. This cleanup improves readability and reduces confusion. When you can distinguish these fields clearly, it makes the code easier to work with.

Overall, these updates reflect a focus on clarity and usability, stripping away unnecessary complexity. The project is cleaner and more coherent as a result.

Gaëtan Gilbert
Enrico Tassi
February

Pierre-Marie Pédrot started the month by moving most of Gramext into Grammar. This was about cleaning up unsafe functions and datatypes that cluttered the grammar engine. Hiding them under the API is a step towards a cleaner design.

He followed up with a commitment to make Grammar truly functorial. The previous setup concealed the reliance on a generic data type. By establishing a clearer dependency on type parameters, the code is now more type-safe, which is essential for robustness.

The pattern continues as he specializes intermediate types within the Grammar functor. Removing unnecessary quantifications simplifies the code further. Each change reflects a consistent effort to enhance clarity and maintainability, shedding complexity in favor of straightforward solutions.

Gaëtan Gilbert then tackled a series of fixes for failing coqtops in documentation files, addressing numerous errors efficiently. With each fix, the documentation becomes more reliable, which is crucial for users relying on it. He also resolved a few bugs related to implicit arguments and evars, ensuring the code behaves as expected.

This ongoing refinement signifies a clear trend: eliminate unnecessary complexity and improve usability. The codebase is evolving, becoming more intuitive and dependable.

Gaëtan Gilbert
Théo Zimmermann
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
Enrico Tassi
Vincent Laporte
Maxime Dénès
Tanaka Akira
Clément Pit-Claudel
Martin Bodin
Pierre Roux
Jasper Hugunin
Jason Gross
Cyril Cohen
March

Matthieu Sozeau fixed the Equation CI script. It’s a straightforward but crucial change. CI scripts are often overlooked until they break, but they’re essential for ensuring the code runs as expected.

An effective CI setup can catch errors early, making development smoother. This fix likely saves time for everyone involved. Clean scripts lead to cleaner workflows, and that’s what matters here. It’s a reminder that sometimes the simplest changes can have big effects on the overall project.

Matthieu Sozeau
May

Hugo Herbelin made a key change by replacing the encoding of implicit arguments with ExplByPos and ExplByName. This adjustment shifts the handling of "n" closer to the user interface, simplifying how arguments are represented. It's a straightforward improvement, but it sets the stage for better usability.

He followed up with more robust tests for manual implicit arguments. The new warnings help catch issues where implicit arguments are misused or duplicated. Allowing local anonymous arguments improves flexibility, while the impl_binder_index flag enhances clarity around when implicit arguments matter.

The focus here is clear: make the code more intuitive and reduce the chances of errors. Each commit builds on the last, indicating a strong commitment to improving both functionality and user experience.

Hugo Herbelin
June

The latest commit from Gaëtan Gilbert restricts the minimization process to a set of flexible elements. This is a practical change that narrows the focus of minimization, likely improving efficiency and clarity.

It's not just a tweak; it addresses specific issues raised in previous discussions (#10331 and #8196) and replaces an earlier, broader approach (#9343). Such refinements are crucial. They prevent unnecessary complexity and make the code easier to maintain.

Each adjustment builds on the last, showing a clear trajectory toward a more streamlined and effective system. This kind of focus on the details is what makes a codebase robust and user-friendly.

Gaëtan Gilbert
August

The handling of artifacts in Dune builds just got a practical upgrade. Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias updated the artifact management process to preserve the _build/log log during CI builds. This change ensures that file permissions are maintained by switching to tar.gz format, which is critical for incremental builds.

Without this fix, using .zip caused permission issues, leading to missed cache hits due to improper executable bits. This isn't just a minor tweak; it’s a necessary adjustment that resolves a specific problem (#10694) and improves the reliability of the build process.

Keeping the focus on the details prevents future headaches. Each commit like this one makes the whole system a bit more resilient, a practice that every developer should prioritize.

Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
September

The commit from Matthieu Sozeau addresses a regression in goal handling. The fix ensures that shelved goals are always marked as non-resolvable. This is crucial because failing to do so creates confusion and can lead to unexpected behavior in the system.

An earlier pull request (#10762) introduced issues that were caught and corrected here. The reference to Arthur indicates that this isn't just a minor oversight; it’s a collective effort to maintain code integrity. The added documentation and comments clarify the changes, making it easier for others to understand the logic.

These straightforward adjustments prevent future regressions and enhance the clarity of the code. Each commit builds on the last, creating a more reliable and maintainable codebase.

Matthieu Sozeau
October

A recent commit revealed that Section.t was never empty. Gaëtan Gilbert proposed a change to the type definition that allows easier updates but limits static checks on section modifications. The alternative suggested, using type t = section * section list, might add complexity but ensures clearer operations on sections.

Next, Pierre-Marie Pédrot removed the unused add_leaves primitive from Libobject. This sort of cleanup is essential. Unused code just weighs down the codebase and makes it harder to navigate.

Olivier Laurent made several integrations, addressing redundancy between skipn_node and skipn_all, and consolidating various statements into the existing structure, including those for rev, concat, and flat_map. These changes eliminate overlap and enhance coherence.

Overall, the focus here is on simplification and clarity, which is crucial for maintainable software development. Each commit, in its own way, contributes to a leaner, more understandable codebase.

Olivier Laurent
Gaëtan Gilbert
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
November

Daniel de Rauglaudre added Nat.bezout_comm, a straightforward addition that enhances mathematical operations.

Hugo Herbelin moved the diversity of constraint printers to a label style. This change allows all printers to access various printing options without bloating the function count. His next commit improved the printing of terms alongside their types, ensuring the context is clear and implicit arguments are handled correctly. Instead of cluttered output, we now get clean, contextual representations.

In a series of commits, Olivier Laurent integrated multiple statements across various functions. This consolidation reduces redundancy and improves coherence in the codebase.

Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias updated to Dune language version 2.0, ensuring compatibility with the latest features while maintaining a minimal set of changes for the build process.

Jason Gross fixed a bug in the time function, making string arguments print correctly. Each commit reflects a steady commitment to clarity and efficiency, driving the project forward without unnecessary complexity.

Olivier Laurent
Hugo Herbelin
Daniel de Rauglaudre
Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
Gaëtan Gilbert
Jason Gross
December

The recent commits show a pragmatic approach to tackling software development challenges, emphasizing clarity and efficiency over unnecessary complexity. Hugo Herbelin fixed a critical issue with pattern-matching decompilation, addressing a missing dependency that could have disrupted the algorithm for default clauses.

Jim Fehrle cleaned up the latex directory by removing files that should be regenerated, preventing potential build failures. Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias consistently merged several PRs that streamlined coercion functions and improved the GUI app’s configuration, ensuring a smoother user experience.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot focused on reducing reliance on outdated patterns in the codebase, removing dead code and simplifying internal flags. This is accompanied by a shift towards type-safe implementations, which eliminates the need for dynamic type casts, reducing runtime costs and potential errors.

Overall, the emphasis is on maintaining a clean, efficient codebase, where every change serves a clear purpose.

Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Hugo Herbelin
Maxime Dénès
Théo Zimmermann
Jim Fehrle
Gaëtan Gilbert
Enrico Tassi
Matthieu Sozeau
charguer
Olivier Laurent
Pierre Courtieu

2020

January

Hugo Herbelin tackled a minor printing bug in tactic notations, addressing an issue that could confuse users. While it’s a small fix, clarity matters, especially in complex systems. He also took the time to document metasyntax.ml, unifying the naming conventions and improving comments. This is the kind of work that often gets overlooked but is crucial for maintainability.

The focus here is on clarity and coherence. When the code is easy to understand, it reduces friction for everyone involved. The changes might seem incremental, but they prevent future confusion and create a more robust foundation. This approach is what keeps the project moving forward.

Hugo Herbelin

2022

January

A confusing name in an evd function was fixed. Clarity in naming is crucial; if a function name misleads, it can derail understanding. This change might seem small, but it directly affects how future developers interact with the code.

Hugo Herbelin didn’t stop there. He also cleaned up the documentation to match this new clarity, ensuring that anyone reading the code can follow along without unnecessary friction.

These updates reflect a broader commitment to maintaining a clean codebase where every detail counts. Fixing names and refining documentation may not grab headlines, but they lay the groundwork for smoother development down the line.

Hugo Herbelin
February

Hugo Herbelin made several small but meaningful changes, focusing on clarity in the codebase. The documentation for declarations.ml received a mini-clarification, addressing confusion and making it easier for developers to understand. This kind of attention to detail matters more than you might think; small clarifications can prevent larger misunderstandings down the line.

He also tackled confusing indentation issues, ensuring that the visual structure of the code matches its logic. If indentation misleads, it can create unnecessary complexity. A clean visual layout helps maintain focus and reduces errors.

Finally, Hugo renamed Univ.Context.Set from ctx to uctx. Renaming variables for clarity might seem cosmetic, but it can significantly improve code readability. These changes emphasize the importance of clear naming and documentation in software development.

Hugo Herbelin
March

The comments in gramlib had inaccuracies. Hugo Herbelin fixed this by correcting the mistakes from commit 8716a37. Clear comments are essential; if they mislead, developers waste time trying to decipher the intent.

This might seem trivial, but it’s part of a bigger picture. Each correction improves the overall understanding of the code. Mistakes in documentation can compound misunderstandings down the road.

Small changes like these aren't glamorous, but they matter. They ensure that anyone diving into the code doesn’t have to second-guess what they read. In software development, clarity isn’t optional; it’s a necessity.

Hugo Herbelin
November

The elimtype and casetype tactics in Ltac were deprecated. Pierre-Marie Pédrot removed them. It’s straightforward: keeping outdated code creates confusion and technical debt. Removing these tactics cleans up the codebase and pushes developers toward using more current methods.

This isn’t just about tidying up. It’s about making it easier for developers to focus on what matters: solving problems without getting bogged down by unnecessary legacy code. Each removal of outdated components reduces potential misunderstandings and streamlines the development process.

These changes might seem minor, but they contribute to a cleaner, more efficient environment. If you want to build something enduring, you have to start by clearing out the clutter.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot

2023

January

Hugo Herbelin streamlined the internal interpretation of CPatNotation to align more closely with CNotation. This adjustment simplifies the conversion from term to pattern, addressing issue #13078 without compromising existing pattern notations.

The next commit built on this by improving the fix for #13078. It now supports "ident" and "pattern" in notations for patterns, replacing an earlier restriction. Simple changes like these can significantly ease the developer experience.

Further, Hugo added a change log for issue #17115 and introduced a function to quote strings according to Coq conventions. He also made minor improvements, like using String.plural where applicable in notation.ml. Lastly, he enabled recognition of string constant tokens in notations, setting the groundwork for more intuitive parsing. Each commit pushes the project towards clearer, more effective code while addressing specific issues head-on.

Hugo Herbelin
February

The change log for issue #17123 is now added. Hugo Herbelin tackled the need for better documentation, making it easier for developers to track changes and understand the project's evolution.

Co-authored by Jim Fehrle , this entry doesn't just document; it serves as a reference point for future work. A well-maintained change log is crucial. It reduces the cognitive load on developers trying to navigate through the codebase.

Documentation is often overlooked, but it’s essential for a clean development process. If you want clarity and efficiency, you can't skip it. Each entry provides context that helps avoid confusion down the line.

Hugo Herbelin
March

The commit history reveals a straightforward evolution of the project. Hugo Herbelin focused on improving the handling of projections in functors. Instead of relying on a table of projections in structure.ml, which was inadequate, he switched to using dot notation. This change makes the code more intuitive and aligns better with how OCaml operates.

Next, he introduced an overlay for the tactician. This addition isn’t just cosmetic; it enhances functionality and improves user interaction. Each step is pragmatic, focusing on making life easier for developers.

These changes are about clarity and efficiency. They refine the existing codebase without introducing unnecessary complexity or bloat. As the project matures, foundational improvements like these set the stage for more advanced features down the line.

Hugo Herbelin
June

Error handling was a mess. Gaëtan Gilbert refactored the virtual machine’s error handling, ensuring it catches errors when the generated code is too large. Instead of raw warnings, it now uses cwarnings for clearer feedback during compilation failures. This is a necessary improvement; developers need actionable information, not just noise.

Ana Borges tackled another pain point by clarifying the duplicate-clear warning message. Clear warnings prevent misunderstandings. If a message is vague, it leads to wasted time figuring out what went wrong. Now, developers can act quickly based on precise feedback.

Pierre-Marie Pédrot simplified the internals of exfalso. Complexity tends to breed bugs. By streamlining the code, he made it easier to understand and maintain. These changes are practical and focused on reducing friction in the development process. Every step is about making the codebase cleaner and more efficient.

Ana Borges
Gaëtan Gilbert
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Théo Zimmermann
July

The project made significant strides this month, focusing on clarity and efficiency. Jan-Oliver Kaiser set a firm rule against backtracking when Typeclasses Unique Instances is enabled, reinforcing a more deterministic approach. Gaëtan Gilbert improved error handling, ensuring that no location information is lost in Tacinterp.wrap_error_loc during tracing. This is a key change; it means developers get complete context when errors occur.

Théo Zimmermann automated the generation of opam files with Dune, making dependency management smoother. Improvements continued with Gaëtan Gilbert's warning for minimizing inductive types when minim to set is off, a practical guide to prevent future pitfalls.

Hugo Herbelin and Pierre-Marie Pédrot cleaned up notations and moved induction-like tactics into their own module. They’re not just tidying up; they’re making the codebase more intuitive. Each contribution reduces complexity, making the project cleaner and easier to work with. These changes lay the groundwork for future developments.

coqbot-app[bot]
Hugo Herbelin
Gaëtan Gilbert
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Théo Zimmermann
Pierre Roux
Emilio Jesus Gallego Arias
Karl Palmskog
Lasse Blaauwbroek
Jan-Oliver Kaiser
J

2024

August

Pierre-Marie Pédrot enforced a rule: metas can't show up in certain areas of the code. Metas should only exist temporarily during unification, and keeping them in the wrong places complicates things unnecessarily. This change aligns the codebase with Coq 8.4 standards, reducing potential confusion and bugs.

Hugo Herbelin made a few consistency updates in List.v, changing O to 0 in names. He also standardized the use of [] for nil and [x] for x::nil, which eliminates ambiguity. Consistency is key; it makes the code easier to read and understand.

Finally, Hugo added some trivial lemmas: length_nil and length_cons. While they might seem basic, these lemmas clarify assumptions about list lengths, contributing to a more robust foundation for future work. Small changes like these matter; they add up to a cleaner, more maintainable codebase.

Hugo Herbelin
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
September

Hugo Herbelin standardized the use of l for lists in pattern matching in List.v. Consistency matters in programming; it eliminates confusion and makes code easier to follow. He also tidied up spacing and replaced the deprecated note with use. These aren’t just cosmetic changes; they reflect a commitment to clarity.

Gaëtan Gilbert rolled back a previous change intended to compact the on-file representation of global anonymous universes. Sometimes, reverting is the right call, particularly when a change complicates things. He then addressed name collisions with autogenerated universe names and streamlined the naming process by generating names from section variables and private constants. This makes the codebase more manageable.

The focus this month was on clarity and consistency, with small but impactful changes that enhance the code's readability and maintainability.

Gaëtan Gilbert
Hugo Herbelin
October

The project is evolving with a focus on clarity, consistency, and performance. Gaëtan Gilbert updated the macOS CI image, reflecting the need for timely maintenance as outdated tools become obsolete. He also removed unnecessary installations and fixed logic errors in load_keep and open_keep. These changes streamline the code, making it easier to navigate.

Further, he improved the handling of universe names and their interactions with modules, which is essential for managing complexity. The removal of recursive values in checker values.ml and the privatization of Value.value enforce better encapsulation.

Andres Erbsen added essential lemmas for list operations and proved important relations between operations on natural numbers. These foundational updates strengthen the code's reliability. Meanwhile, Pierre-Marie Pédrot refined meta-handling, ensuring they stay within the bounds of unification, thus reducing potential bugs.

The consistent push for clarity and performance is evident throughout the latest commits.

coqbot-app[bot]
Gaëtan Gilbert
Hugo Herbelin
Andres Erbsen
Pierre-Marie Pédrot
Jim Fehrle
Pierre Roux
November

The project is simplifying. A significant update reduced the dependency on metas throughout the codebase. This makes the logic clearer and less prone to errors.

Recent fixes addressed specific issues, like an anomaly in printing functors. These are the types of problems that can confuse users and developers alike. The addition of checks in plugins/extraction/scheme.ml ensures that edge cases are handled, improving the overall robustness.

Changes to how universe names are handled show a careful approach to maintainability. The decision to shorten artifact expiration to one week for most, while keeping documentation at two months, reflects an understanding of resource management. Updates to the CI configurations ensure the build environment remains current. All these adjustments are practical steps toward a more reliable and easier-to-understand codebase.

coqbot-app[bot]
Gaëtan Gilbert
Siegmentation Fault

Have a legacy codebase in mind?

Curious about the story behind a specific legacy codebase? Let us help you uncover its legacy.